| Feature / Aspect | Batzal Roof Designer (Legacy) | RailClone (iToo Software) | ATiles (AvizStudio) | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | | Quick, automated roof tile generation on simple to moderate roof forms. | Creating all types of parametric models, from complex roofing to railings and walls. | Quickly tiling repetitive geometry across surfaces, like roof tiles or brick walls. | | Core Approach | Dedicated Roof Modifier - Apply directly to a mesh and configure parameters. | Procedural Array - Build complex models by defining rules for how geometry is scattered along splines or surfaces. Requires a learning curve. | Simple Tiling Script - Scatter geometry across a plane or along a path with control over spacing. | | Complexity | Low. Very easy to learn and apply for basic roof shapes. | High . A powerful but complex node-based system. Mastery unlocks vast potential. | Low . Very easy to use for straightforward tiling tasks. | | Modern Features | None (unsupported). | Full support for up-to-date 3ds Max versions, active development, extensive library, and high performance. | Full support, regular updates, and an active development community. | | Control | High-level control over roof and tile parameters. | Maximum control at every level. Build any conceivable structure. | Direct control over the tiling pattern, geometry, and placement. |
: A highly recommended, modern scripted plugin that creates roof tiles, bricks, and fences. It is known for its speed and compatibility with newer Max versions. batzal roof designer for max 2020
: By selecting specific edges, users can auto-generate highly detailed ridge caps with customizable height, width, and angle parameters. | Feature / Aspect | Batzal Roof Designer
: Official development of the plugin ceased years ago, with native .dlo or .dlm compiled plugin binaries stopping around the 3ds Max 2014 lifecycle. | | Core Approach | Dedicated Roof Modifier
Once satisfied, apply a Multi/Sub-Object material to the roof for texturing.